preload
Sep 02

It's dangerous to go alone... take this TING! with you!Click for full image

Andrew T Comments: Darth Vader, before he had the Death Star, trained crows each winter.
Published 1978

Actually, that cover IS a classical work of artI would touch it without protective glovesI have seen worse. Far, far worseInteresting, but I would still read it in publicMiddling: Neither awful nor awfully goodWould not like to be seen reading that!Awful... just awful...That belongs in a gold-lamé picture frame!Gah... my eyes are burning! Feels so good!Good Show, Sir.... Good Show! (Average: 8.54 out of 10)
Loading ... Loading ...

Tagged with:

26 Responses to “The Weirdstone of Brisingamen”

  1. Phil Says:

    1978, eh? Did George Lucas know about this?

    Nice to see a swordless TING! – it proves they can exist independently.

    Surely worthy of a “font problem” tag – no caps, horrible drop shadow, an unusual sense of alignment.

  2. James Says:

    crow looks happy

  3. The Tag Wizard Says:

    Phil, that is some serious drop shadowing! Font problems bestowed.

  4. andy Says:

    Are the Lord of the Rings boys sneaking up on the His Imperial Darkness?

    [Apologies, Andy - our spam system erroneously confused your comment with a shiny lump of spam. TW 09/30]

  5. THX 1138 Says:

    Klytus, I’m bored. What plaything can you offer me today?

  6. Dead Stuff With Big Teeth Says:

    ‘Shhh…be vewwy vewwy quiet…we’we huntin’ Dawth Vadows…huhhuhuhuh!’

  7. Bibliomancer Says:

    Did his three buddies in the background build a snowman to have a sword fight with?

  8. Tom Hering Says:

    Trick or treat, Mr. Brisingamen! Wait … this is all you’re handing out? Shiny pebbles? Don’t try pulling this crap on the other kids behind me, Mr. Brisingamen. They’ve got weapons!

  9. fred Says:

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Weirdstone_of_Brisingamen

    “However, within several years Garner had begun to find fault with his debut; in a 1968 interview he referred to it as “a fairly bad book” whilst in 1970 he derided it as “one of the worst books published in the last twenty years… technically… inept”.”

  10. Tat Wood Says:

    @fred: even bad Garner (and his opinion of his own books is suspect, especially after his 68 breakdown prompted by Granada’s version of ‘The Owl Service’) is better than Lucas.

    As for the cover… I wonder if this is how Lucasfilms and New Line have decided to combat the threat of Marvel/Disney/Pixar : Vader vs Gandalf – ON ICE.

  11. Jane Says:

    Those guys in back are rolling stats for their characters.

  12. Tom Noir Says:

    The cover is inoffensive… but that font! Oh my.

  13. Sarah J Says:

    no really dude! Brisingamen said it took three days to pass this thing

  14. Rachel J Says:

    Maybe covers like this are *why* Garner started hating the book? (Which is really pretty good, by the way.)

  15. Dead Stuff With Big Teeth Says:

    I can see why Garner would grow to dislike it. The summary above sounds much like Susan Cooper’s books, not because they are derivative so much as they share similar source material. Now, again, that’s not to fault either book. My point is that as the 60s and 70s wore on, the novelty of adapting the myths from the British Isles wore off. It sounds like Garner wanted to judge his own writing on its merits and faults in toto. And if you’re disappointed by your own characterization, or your writing style in your 23rd year (heaven knows, I am!), while your innovations to setting haven’t aged well, then I think you have a legitimate complaint.

    Also, I finally twigged to what the cover reminds me of: the film version of Cooper’s book! Look at Eccleston’s outfit and tell me it doesn’t remind you of Darth Moper. Read how useless the B cast are, and tell me they don’t look as ineffectual as that lot in the back.

  16. Rachel J Says:

    @Dead Stuff. Yes, but, you see, I’ve actually read the book, so this is my own personal view– which I believe is also legitimate. Not that the thing doesn’t indeed have significant flaws– it’s a first novel, after all– but his condemnation seems extremely over-the-top to me. But then authors *are* often like that about their early work.

    EDIT: By personal view, I mean, “the view that this is actually a good book”, not that it was the Vader-on-Ice cover which did the damage. Though really, who knows?

  17. SI Says:

    NOOO don’t take it! He’s evil!

    http://www.goodshowsir.co.uk/2009/03/black-company/

  18. B. Chiclitz Says:

    Never fully believe or see as definitive an author’s judgment of his or her own work: 1. they often lie; 2. they often don’t fully grasp what they’ve written; 3. (following from 2) they have their own view of their work which perhaps shouldn’t be privileged above the reader’s.

    Anthony Burgess went to his grave protesting loudly that A Clockwork Orange was a terrible book and that he’d written at least a dozen that were much better, but he was wrong. It’s clearly, as posterity has made clear, out of his forty or so works, his one and only masterpiece.

    cf. the New Critics and “The Intentional Fallacy.”

  19. Stevie T Says:

    I see the Disneyfication of Star Wars continues as they remake “Beauty and the Beast” with Vader recast as The Beast. (I can hear the dialogue now: “You’re supposed to be feeding the birds, not Force Choking them!”)

  20. Dead Stuff With Big Teeth Says:

    @ST: ‘Be our…*hsss*…guest, be…*hsss*…our guest…*hsss*…fights with Gandalf…*hsss*…by request!’

  21. A.R.Yngve Says:

    “I find your lack of bird seed disturbing.” (Come on, you were ALL thinking of that one.)

  22. Lionrock Says:

    I always thought Vader was missing a nice set of mirrored shades.

    It’d be like he was from the Deep South.

    *wheeze* Hey boy! *Hiss* Boy ah’m talkin’ to ya boy! *Wheeze* Y’all don’ know the power o’the dark side! *Hiss* Dagnabbit!*wheeze*

  23. Dead Stuff With Big Teeth Says:

    ‘Luke…I am your feather…’

    I’ll get me coat.

  24. eliddell Says:

    $DEITY, that font . . . Ace had a real thing for it, back then. Or at least, I’m pretty sure I’ve got a copy of Norton’s Breed to Come with the exact same font on the cover, right down to the drop shadow.

  25. Anti-Sceptic Says:

    “Ok, who put this tack under my chair?”

  26. A.R.Yngve Says:

    [In James Earl Jones voice]
    “Birdy…. [*PUFF* *WHEEZE*] birdy nam nam…”

Leave a Reply